A study of Black women diagnosed with breast cancer found that those with the highest intake of ultra-processed foods had a 40% higher relative rate of breast cancer mortality than those with the lowest intake. What does that finding mean, and what should we take away from it?
In this episode, I explain what the research tells us, why it does not establish that ultra-processed foods cause breast cancer deaths, and why we need to be careful about interpreting these results. I also clarify the difference between processed and ultra-processed foods. Frozen vegetables and canned beans, for example, can be convenient, nutritious choices.
Food choices matter, but so do food affordability, access to nutritious options, cancer stage, tumor biology, treatment, and access to care. Healthy eating advice must account for these realities rather than assume everyone has the same resources and options.
For breast cancer survivors, this research is not a reason to blame yourself for your diagnosis or outcome. Instead, it offers an opportunity to look at dietary quality and consider manageable changes that support overall health, without fear, guilt, or the expectation of eating perfectly.
Episode Highlights:
-
What a study of 1,733 Black women with breast cancer found about ultra-processed food intake and breast cancer mortality
-
Why a 40% higher relative rate does not mean a 40% chance of dying from breast cancer
-
What observational research can and cannot tell us about food choices and cancer outcomes
-
Why frozen vegetables and canned beans can still be part of a nutritious diet
-
How overall dietary quality, calorie intake, and metabolic health may relate to the findings
-
Why food affordability and access must be part of the conversation about nutrition
-
Practical ways to improve dietary quality without eliminating every packaged food
-
Why breast cancer outcomes depend on many factors, and why this research is not a reason to blame yourself
Free or low cost mammogram:
-
Susan B Komen foundation. Breast Care Helpline: Call 1-877-GO-KOMEN (1-877-465-6636)
-
National Breast and Cervical Cancer Early Detection Program (NBCCEDP): Provides free or low-cost mammograms to uninsured or underinsured individuals ages 40 to 64 meeting income guidelines. Call 1-800-232-4636 or visit the CDC Website.
-
American Cancer Society: Call 1-800-227-2345 for local screening resources.
-
American Breast Cancer Foundation: Apply for assistance through their Breast Cancer Assistance Program.
Connect with Dr. Alicia Shelly
-
Website | drshellymd.com
-
Facebook | www.facebook.com/drshellymd
-
Instagram | @drshellymd
-
Linked In | www.linkedin.com/in/drshellymd
-
Twitter | @drshellymd
About Dr. Alicia Shelly
Dr. Alicia Shelly was raised in Atlanta, GA. She received her Doctorate of Medicine from Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine in Cleveland, OH. Dr. Shelly has been practicing Primary Care and Obesity medicine since 2014. In 2017, she became a Diplomat of the American Board of Obesity Medicine. She is the lead physician at the Wellstar Medical Center Douglasville.
She started a weekly podcast & Youtube channel entitled Back on Track: Achieving Healthy Weight loss, where she discusses how to get on track and stay on track with your weight loss journey. She has spoken for numerous local and national organizations, including the Obesity Medicine Association, and the Georgia Chapter of the American Society of Metabolic and Bariatric Surgeons. She has been featured on CNN, Fox 5 News, Bruce St. James Radio show, Upscale magazine, and Shape.com.
She was named an honoree of the 2021 Atlanta Business Chronicle's 40 under 40 award. She also is a collaborating author for the, “Made for More: Physician Entrepreneurs who Live Life and Practice Medicine on their own terms''.
Resources:
FREE! Discover the 5 Reasons Your Weight-Loss Journey Has Gotten Derailed (And How To Get Back On Track!) 👉 Click HERE
[00:00:00] Welcome back to the Back on Track: Achieving Healthy Weight Loss, where I help you get on track and stay on track with your weight loss journey. I'm your host, Dr. Alicia Shelly. So let's get started.
[00:00:27] Welcome back to the Back on Track Achieving Healthy Weight Loss podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Alicia Shelly. Now, October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month. And in 2025, there was an estimate of around 317,000 new breast cancer cases in the U.S. And there was 42,000 to 43,000 deaths due to breast cancer in 2025 in the U.S.
[00:00:56] And in 2022, it was reported that 2.3 million new breast cancer cases are occurring globally. So this is a condition that is affecting many, many different people. And in fact, they have noted that there's been an increase, a 1% increase of breast cancer developing each year in the U.S. each year from 2012 to 2022. And I want to point out that breast cancer just does not only affect women.
[00:01:26] It can also affect men. And so if you have not gotten your mammogram, then you should definitely get it scheduled. And if you have no insurance or under insurance, there are many programs that can give you a voucher to help get your mammogram at free or low cost. So check with the Susan B. Komen Foundation. They actually have a helpline called 1-877-GO-KOMEN, C-K-O-M-E-N.
[00:01:53] And there are other organizations that also offer free or low cost mammograms. And I will put that information at the show notes. But the reason why I bring that up is that I recently came across a study that caught my attention. And it asked the question, what if the foods we eat every day could be associated with our chance of surviving breast cancer? Now, in my family, we've had several family members, my grandmother and aunt, who have developed breast cancer.
[00:02:23] So definitely this is a very close subject for me. And it's so important that we do the best we can to prevent, to screen and to make sure and get treated if we do have breast cancer. And so I wanted to just share with you this study. It was out of the Rutgers University, published in the eClinical Medicine Journal. And what it looked at was the ultra-processed food consumption and mortality among Black women diagnosed with breast cancer.
[00:02:52] And the findings were very significant. Women who reported consuming higher amounts of ultra-processed foods before their diagnosis and approximately 40% had higher breast cancer-related mortality rates. And 36% higher overall mortality rates compared with women consuming the lowest amounts.
[00:03:15] So what that means, if you're eating a lot of ultra-processed foods and you develop breast cancer, your risk of dying from breast cancer is a lot higher than somebody who is consuming low amounts of ultra-processed food. Now, before you start throwing everything away in your pantry, I want us to understand what this research actually means. Does eating ultra-processed foods cause cancer? Does it mean you cannot eat bread, cereal, or your other favorite snacks?
[00:03:44] And what should breast cancer survivors actually be eating during, you know, treatment and after treatment? So I plan to break down all the research, discuss the potential biological mechanisms, and talk about practical changes you can make without feeling overwhelmed. So let's start off with what exactly are ultra-processed foods?
[00:04:08] First, we need to understand what I mean by that, because not all processed foods are created equal. For example, frozen vegetables that you get from the refrigerator aisle in the grocery store are processed. They have to process them to freeze them. Canned beans that are in a can are processed. Pasteurized milk is processed. And these foods can absolutely be part of a healthy diet.
[00:04:34] Researchers commonly use something called the NOVA, NOVA classification system. This divides foods into four categories. Group one, unprocessed or minimally processed foods. These are like your fresh fruits that you get at the grocery store, your vegetables, fresh vegetables, eggs, beans, plain yogurt, and fresh meats. And then you have group two, which is your processed culinary ingredients.
[00:05:00] So this is like your oils, your butter, your sugar, salt that we use to prepare food. And then we have three processed foods. So this can include your canned vegetables, because they had to process it to put it in a can, because it does have some added salt to preserve it to be on the shelf and to make sure that it's shelf stable. Also, some cheeses are processed as well. Freshly baked breads are processed. You know, you have to bake them, put them in the oven and things like that.
[00:05:28] And usually it does have some simple ingredients. But then you get to your ultra processed foods. And this is where we find to be a little bit more challenging. These are your typically industrial formulations that contain ingredients or a lot more additives, not commonly used in home cooking. So if you were going to read the package label and you couldn't understand or pronounce some of the words on the back of that, those are the additives that we're talking about.
[00:05:56] And so some examples of ultra processed foods includes sugary sodas, energy drinks, packaged cookies and snack cakes, certain breakfast cereals that have a lot of sugar on them, instant noodles. Oh, I love a good noodle. Some packaged frozen meals, processed meat products like bologna, you know, and then certain processed breads and snack foods. But here is something that I do want you to understand.
[00:06:24] Not every ultra processed food has the same nutritional profile. There are high fiber whole grain breads and packaged snack cakes that might both fall under ultra processed category, but they are not necessarily nutritionally equivalent. So the whole grain bread has probably more better nutrition than the snack cake.
[00:06:45] So what I want you to do is rather than focusing only on whether food comes in a package, we also need to consider what's its nutritional quality. So let's go back to the study that I just mentioned. What did Rutgers study actually find? So this study was led by researchers affiliated with the Rutgers Cancer Institute and published in the e-clinical medicine and this year in 2026.
[00:07:10] The researchers followed around 17, 133 black women who had been diagnosed with breast cancer in New Jersey between 2005 and 2019. They examined the women's reported dietary intake during the year before their breast cancer was diagnosed. And then they looked at the mortality outcomes over a median follow-up of around 9.3 years.
[00:07:33] During that period, out of that 1,700 women that had breast cancer, 394 of those women died from all causes. So it could have been a heart attack, it could have been a stroke, it could have been other things. But 206 of those deaths were actually attributed to their breast cancer. So their breast cancer led to their death. The researchers divided the participants into three groups based on their ultra-processed food consumption.
[00:07:59] The lowest consumption group had a median intake of approximately 2.6 servings of ultra-processed foods daily, whereas the highest consumption group had a median intake of approximately 8.1 servings daily. And what they found was that the women in the highest consumption group of around 8.1 servings per daily had a 40% higher relative rate of breast cancer-specific mortality compared with those in the lowest group.
[00:08:27] So those who ate more ultra-processed foods had a 40% higher chance of dying from breast cancer-related causes. They also, in that high consumption group, had a 35% relative rate of death from any other causes. So it put them at increased risk from dying from other causes, which could have been a heart attack, a stroke, or something else because of their high consumption group.
[00:08:54] Now, I do want to emphasize something, that this does not mean that 40% of women who eat ultra-processed food will die from breast cancer. We don't have that knowledge because this is more of a cohort-type study or an observational study. You have two groups, people who have a low consumption and those who have a higher consumption, and they also have breast cancer. And then you kind of watch them over time to see what happens.
[00:09:19] It's not necessarily the best study to look to see if ultra-processed food causes breast cancer death. It doesn't necessarily depict that because there's so many other factors. But it is interesting that there is a higher rate of those who pass away with breast cancer-related causes and those people who are eating more ultra-processed foods.
[00:09:43] So I do want to make sure that this is important, different, and should be understood because we don't have all the facts because it is an observational study. Also, the one thing I want to mention is that researchers also found that when they accounted for the total caloric intake, the associations became a little bit weaker.
[00:10:02] Meaning that if there was one group that ate a lot more calories, like ate like 3,000 calories, and this lower group ate like 1,000 calories, when they actually made sure that they were eating around the same caloric intake, the association for breast cancer was lower. And it raises the important question, is the concern related to the processing of the food itself? Or is it the higher caloric intake associated with these foods? Or the nutritional quality? Or some combination?
[00:10:31] And that's an area that we need more researchers to investigate, to be honest. So this study just kind of tells us that, hmm, we need to look a little bit more further into this. But let's look to see why might ultra-processed foods affect cancer outcomes. And there are some possible biological explanations. Number one, chronic inflammation.
[00:10:53] Many dietary patterns high in ultra-processed foods are also high in refined carbohydrates, lots of added sugars, certain fats, while being lower in fiber and other beneficial nutrients. And these dietary patterns may contribute to chronic inflammation. And inflammation plays a complex role in cancer biology, also including in pathways involved in tumor growth and progression.
[00:11:21] However, this particular study did not really establish inflammation as the mechanism responsible for the findings. We weren't able to really look at that. But that's just a possible pathway that you can see with it. Another pathway is insulin resistance and metabolic health. This is especially relevant to obesity medicine. Some ultra-processed foods are easy to consume quickly and may contribute to excess caloric intake.
[00:11:47] Over time, that excess energy intake can contribute to weight gain and metabolic dysfunction. And obesity and insulin resistance are associated with changes in insulin signaling and other metabolic pathways that may influence certain cancer outcomes. But remember, we cannot assume that every ultra-processed food produces these effects or that weight explains the entire relationship. Because it's definitely multifactorial.
[00:12:15] Another pathway that we need to look at is the gut microbiome. Our gut contains trillions of microorganisms that help regulate digestion, immune function, and metabolism. Dietary patterns that are low in fiber have been shown to cause an adverse effect or a negative effect on the gut microbiome. And researchers are also studying whether certain food adages influence intestinal functioning and inflammation.
[00:12:45] There is an emerging area of research, and we need more human studies before drawing definitive conclusions about cancer survival with the gut microbiome. But that's just one other pathway. And then the last pathway that we can see is a nutritional displacement. This may be one of the most practical concepts for our listeners because sometimes the concern is not only what we are eating, but also what we are not eating.
[00:13:09] When much of our diet consists of sugary diet, sugary drinks, packaged snacks, convenience foods, we may consume fewer vegetables, fruits, beans, legumes, and fiber-rich whole grains. And those foods provide nutrients that support our overall health. So the goal is not to simply remove foods. It is to improve the overall quality of our dietary pattern. So why does this research matter for Black women?
[00:13:39] Now, I want to spend a moment kind of discussing why this study is particularly important. Because Black women in the United States experience a disproportionately high breast cancer mortality compared with white women. And we need to understand that these disparities are not explained by individual dietary choices alone. I mean, there are other factors such as access to screening. Are we getting our mammograms every year like we should be doing?
[00:14:06] You know, and if we do get them, are we being diagnosed properly? Timely diagnosis. Are they seeing that change and say, hey, we need to get a biopsy? Or, hey, we need to have you see the breast cancer, the breast specialist. And then when there is a concern, are we getting proper treatment, cancer treatment? Are we getting the cutting edge? Are we getting old treatment that may or may not be as effective? Because our insurance may not cover it. And then that goes into insurance coverage.
[00:14:36] Sometimes insurances may not go for the latest and greatest, you know, cutting edge treatment. They may go for what has been around for a long time because it's least expensive. And then also, you know, structural barriers, racism, biases that still exist to this day. And then also looking at the differences in tumor biology also can contribute.
[00:15:01] So there's many factors that contribute to the disparities that we see among the high breast cancer mortality in black women in the U.S. And the one reason why this study matters is that black women have historically been underrepresented in many areas of clinical research. It is hard to get people of African-American descent to want to participate. And a lot of it is because we were so exploited for generations in these studies. And it's been documented.
[00:15:30] I saw a documentary several years ago looking at how black women slaves, when looking at how to do hysterectomies, were, you know, put under. Like, you know, actually they weren't even put under. They were awake when they did these surgeries because they didn't think black women would respond to pain. So, you know, definitely the past affects how many people are going to be willing to be a clinical research subject because the fear is we won't get the proper care because it happened.
[00:16:00] And it happened like the Tuskegee experiment was in the 1970s. So it wasn't like this was just 100 years ago. No, this was less than 100 years ago. And so I do want to make something very clear. We cannot place the burden of cancer survival entirely on what somebody chooses to eat. But can healthy eating influence by income, food prices, neighborhood, grocery access, work schedules, caregiving?
[00:16:26] Could that help all these other factors make cancer survival difficult? And I would say probably, yes, that social determinants of health plays a big role on the care that people get. And the one thing I would say, especially being an obesity medicine doctor, you know, I can tell somebody to eat some fresh vegetables, but it's another thing to make sure that those vegetables are affordable and accessible.
[00:16:52] And the one conversation I had with a patient just last week, it was like, listen, you know, money's tight. And I can't be spending all the money I have on fresh vegetables when I have to make sure that we have food for the month. And I get that. I definitely understand. And I definitely feel like there is there is more areas where opportunities for where we can help with having more food access and treating food insecurity for sure.
[00:17:19] So when we discuss nutrition and cancer survivorship, it is important that we also discuss access and equity as well. And when I say equity, I mean food equity. Like if we look at these inner cities or even rural areas, we'll find that there's food deserts, that there's not a grocery store like around the corner that you can go to.
[00:17:45] You have to get on a bus, go 5, 10, 20 miles just to get to the local grocery store. I have patients who live in the rural part of Georgia and they have to take a whole, you know, 30 minutes to an hour driving to the next Walmart to get access to fresh fruits and vegetables. So, you know, let's talk about what we can actually do with this information.
[00:18:09] Because I never want to leave this podcast feeling like you need to completely overhaul your lifestyle overnight or feeling overwhelmed. But I think the first tip number one that we need to do is to start with your beverages. If you regularly drink sugar sodas, sweetened teas or energy drinks, consider gradually replacing some of them with water, unsweetened tea or low sugar options.
[00:18:34] They have a lot of low sugar carbonated beverages that can maybe take the place of those sodas and at least give you the fizziness that you're looking for. And then also it's just a relatively simple way to reduce added sugar to your intake. And then tip number two is adding more fiber to your diet because fiber supports digestive and metabolic health.
[00:18:58] And you can do this by adding beans, lentils, vegetables, fruits, oatmeal and whole grains. And like I said, even though frozen vegetables can be considered somewhat processed and canned beans can be somewhat processed.
[00:19:11] Because if you are undergoing some food insecurity where it's just still have the money, not in the budget, then these are other options that can still give you good nutrients because they can the beans and they freeze the fruit, the vegetables at the highest of quality. Can give you nutrients there and can be another way how to get it in without necessarily spending an almond like. And no, you don't have to make all your food from scratch.
[00:19:38] Those frozen vegetables and canned beans can be convenient, affordable and nutritious. So tip number three, prioritize protein. For cancer survivors, adequate protein intake can be especially important for maintaining muscle mass, particularly during recovery, especially from chemo or radiation. So make sure you're getting your fish, your chicken, your eggs, Greek yogurt, tofu, beans and lentils or just some examples of protein.
[00:20:05] And I though I recognize protein needs should be individualized based on your current wage, your activity level, certain medical conditions like chronic kidney disease. So make sure you talk to your doctor about how much protein you should be eating. But during your active cancer treatment or when other medical conditions are present, it's important to make sure you talk with your teens so they know how much protein you should be getting in. All right. Tip number four, make convenient foods work for you. I totally get it.
[00:20:34] People are so busy. But sometimes you may need to eat a frozen meal or something quick and that's OK. But look at those nutritional labels. Look at the overall nutritional quality and ask yourself, does this meal provide protein? Does it contain vegetables or fiber? Is it high in sodium or added sugar? A convenient meal can still contribute to a nutritious dietary pattern. And then the last tip, tip number five, focus on progress, not perfection.
[00:21:01] This is probably my favorite recommendation and quote and saying, you don't need to eliminate every ultra processed food. Maybe this week you replace one sugary drink each day. Next week you add a serving of vegetables to dinner. The following week you prepare breakfast at home for a few mornings. Small, sustainable changes are often more realistic than an extremely restricted diet.
[00:21:24] And for someone living with cancer or recovering from treatment, nutrition must also account for appetite, nausea, weight changes, and the need to maintain adequate nourishment. So before we wrap up, I want to address a few limitations of this study. First off, this is an observational study. They had a group of women who had breast cancer, who had either higher consumption of ultra processed food and lower consumption of ultra processed food.
[00:21:52] And they just followed them to see what happened over nine years. And although it identified an association between dietary intake and mortality, it does not prove cause and effect. And second, the researchers assessed dietary intake from the year before the diagnosis. So therefore, this study does not directly tell us whether the reducing ultra processed food after breast cancer diagnosis improved survival.
[00:22:19] So thirdly, the dietary intake was self-reported and people's diets can change over time. And it did not, this study did not reflect that. Fourth, the study cannot tell us that every ultra processed food carries the same risk. We don't have that data. And finally, the finding of a non-linear relationship does not establish a safe or recommended daily number of ultra processed food servings.
[00:22:42] So I would not recommend that everybody count how much ultra processed food servings or try to stay under a particular number based on this one study alone. Instead, I would focus on an overall dietary pattern that emphasizes nutrient dense foods and helps you to have better quality of foods when you eat in general. And here's what I want you to remember from today's episode. Nutrition is an important part of a long term health, including cancer survivorship.
[00:23:12] This study adds to a growing body of research suggesting that diets high in ultra processed foods may be associated with poor health outcomes. But your diet is only one part of the picture. Cancer survival is influenced by many factors, including tumor biology. Like, you know, are you stage four versus stage one? That makes a difference when you have cancer. What type of treatment you get, your access to care.
[00:23:39] Like, when did they find it right away and you got treatment right away? Or was there years before you got treatment? And basically, your overall health. How healthy were you prior to getting having cancer? That makes a big difference, too. And if you are a breast cancer survivor, please do not interpret this research as a reason to blame yourself for your diagnosis or your outcomes. This is just a part of a growing research where we need to look more into how diet plays a role.
[00:24:06] And I want you to use this as an opportunity to think about small changes that can support your health in general. And if you are currently undergoing cancer treatment, stay strong. You know, work with your oncology team and register dietitian to develop an individualized nutrition plan. Because remember, this podcast is for education only. It does not trump what your oncology and chemo team are telling you. They are number one.
[00:24:34] So make sure you see your doctor because they know what's going on with you individually. And remember, you do not have to be perfect to make progress. I thank you so much for joining me today on the Back on Track Achieving Healthy Weight Loss podcast. If you found today's episode helpful, share it with someone who needs to hear it. And don't forget to like and subscribe to our podcast so you get a notification on our next week's podcast as well.
[00:25:01] And until next time, stay strong, stay committed, and stay consistent. And remember, we are stronger together. We are stronger together.
